By Nick Carey
Fri Mar 23, 2007
(Reuters) – In a month or two, Jose Cortez will likely lose the home he wanted
for his children. But he says that’s not what bothers him most.
“I wanted to consolidate my debts, but everything
the brokers said they would do was a lie,” he said, waving a sheaf of documents
in the basement apartment where he, his wife and four children live.
Many minorities in Chicago
are facing the same predicament as the 57-year-old Mexican-born maintenance
worker, according to several nonprofit organizations. Some unscrupulous and unregulated
mortgage brokers arranged for low-income families to take out loans they could
not afford, the groups said.
The nonprofit Woodstock Institute released a study this
month that said Latino borrowers in Chicago
were 3.2 times more likely than whites to pay more for loans; African Americans
were 4.2 times more likely.
“The main feeding ground for predatory subprime
mortgage brokers is in poor, minority communities,” said Michael van
Zalingen, director of housing ownership services at Neighborhood Housing
Services of Chicago, a nonprofit community lender and financial counseling
Subprime, or high-risk, borrowers like Cortez are causing
concern on Wall Street and in Washington
as foreclosures rise amid falling house prices and higher interest rates.
In October, a year after buying his dream home in a
western suburb of Chicago, Cortez
said a mortgage broker promised to consolidate his debts and refinance his
Pressured to sign confusing legal documents at 11 p.m., he said his mortgage rose $70,000 —
on top of $290,000 he already owed. But his debts weren’t covered and he was
charged tens of thousands of dollars in fees and a cancellation payment on his
existing mortgage, which he was not told about beforehand.
“How can they lie like that, in America?”
Now he cannot afford his mortgage and will soon default.
Cortez makes $35,000 a year and has a poor credit
history. Oliver Marquez, a financial counselor at the nonprofit Resurrection
Project who advised Cortez, said the original $290,000 mortgage was well beyond
“Cortez can’t afford that house. He never
could,” Marquez said. “The broker used predatory tactics and
irregular practices like turning up late at night and the result is a loan
beyond his means. … We’re seeing an awful lot of this.”
In 2006, foreclosures nationwide were up 42 percent from
2005, and will likely rise by up to 25 percent this year, according to real
estate information service RealtyTrac Inc.
RealtyTrac puts the number of 2006 foreclosures in Chicago’s
up 79 percent from 2005.
which includes Chicago and many
suburbs, is about 20 percent Latino, according to U.S. Census data.
Some experts warn they are beginning to see people in the
higher “Alt-A” credit category struggling with mortgages sold as a
result of profligate and irresponsible lending.
Such loans were originally aimed at people who were
self-employed or worked commission jobs, who had good credit but didn’t have
pay stubs showing predictable income. More recently, some lenders have offered
Alt-A loans to people who lacked sufficient documentation to get a traditional
Geoff Smith, project
director at the Woodstock Institute, said his group has been warning of the
dangers of lending practices in the subprime sector since 1998.
“Anyone following subprime mortgage lending has been
waiting some time for the other shoe to fall,” he said.
On Pulaski Street,
a few miles southwest of downtown Chicago,
colorful signs proclaim in Spanish that borrowers can get a mortgage with no
documentation and no down payment.
Livia Villareal, a housing counselor at Greater Southwest
Development Corporation, said many of the mortgage brokers preying on the local
community are Latinos.
“In poorer minority communities that have been
neglected by mainstream banks, brokers from their own communities take
advantage of unsophisticated borrowers,” she said. “The majority had
no idea what they were going to sign and many had to no way to pay off these